Strong buy, buy, hold, reduce or sell : Indian stock broker point of view

[slstock]

I went through a research report for Pirmal Glas INDIA ( not our glas.n) recently. At below link.

http://www.fullertonsecurities.co.in/equity/markets/rsch_reports/1_0_04112011Fullerton%20Piramal%20Glass%204th%20Nov%202011.pdf


It would be interesting to compare and contrast the difference from CSE (vs Indian Market)

a) for their recommendations on what is a strong buy, buy sell etc is
b) their recommendation period ( hold times)

I extract their ( fullerton securities) recommendation strategy below

a)

Strong Buy – Expected Returns > 20% p.a.
Buy – Expected Returns from 10 to 20% p.a.
Hold – Expected Returns from 0 % to 10% p.a.
Reduce – Expected Returns from 0 % to 10% p.a. with possible downside risk
Sell – Returns < 0 %

b) Recommendation periods

less than 1 year ( maybe short term)
1-2 years ( maybe medium term)
2-5 years ( maybe longer term)

What do you think about return percentages and investment times. Yes some factors in India does not attribute to CSE but mind you this is in our neighbor.

How can we compare CSE with these time frames and return percentages.

[npp]

In CSE, most at present do not consider the "pa", they want it per DAY!

[Kumar]

Yes for a investor point of view, what they proposed will work even in CSE.
But I'm afraid the present trend in this forum won't accept these good points no?
Thanks a lot for sharing the constructive thought.

[sriranga]

a)

Strong Buy – Expected Returns > 20% p.a.
Buy – Expected Returns from 10 to 20% p.a.
Hold – Expected Returns from 0 % to 10% p.a.
Reduce – Expected Returns from 0 % to 10% p.a. with possible downside risk
Sell – Returns < 0 %

b) Recommendation periods

less than 1 year ( maybe short term)
1-2 years ( maybe medium term)
2-5 years ( maybe longer term)

What do you think about return percentages and investment times. Yes some factors in India does not attribute to CSE but mind you this is in our neighbor.

How can we compare CSE with these time frames and return percentages.

IMHO in CSE very few companies will fall under Strong Buy signal.
Investor point of view recommendation period seems to be applicable even in CSE.
Thanks for sharing.